Excel MCP Server vs Ha MCP
Two MCP servers from our automation ranking, compared on live data - updated nightly, never sponsored.
Bottom line · 2026-09-30
Ha MCP records more monthly package installs (284,284 vs 132,122); both are actively maintained, with commits inside the last month.
How they differ in kind
Excel MCP Server focuses on: A Model Context Protocol server that lets AI assistants create, read and edit Excel workbooks. Ha MCP focuses on: A comprehensive Model Context Protocol (MCP) server that enables AI assistants to interact with Home Assistant. Environment-variable extraction: Excel MCP Server yielded 1 variable; Ha MCP yielded no variables extracted.
What each one does
Excel MCP Server
A Model Context Protocol server that lets AI assistants create, read and edit Excel workbooks. It needs no Microsoft Excel installation. It runs locally over stdio via the published package.
From the project's README.
Ha MCP
A comprehensive Model Context Protocol (MCP) server that enables AI assistants to interact with Home Assistant. It runs locally over stdio via the published package.
From the project's README.
14 signals, side by side
| Signal | Excel MCP Server | Ha MCP |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly installs | 132,122 | 284,284 |
| GitHub stars | 4,205 | 4,894 |
| Last commit | 2026-09-28 | 2026-09-29 |
| Releases · last 90 days | 3 | 5 |
| In the registry since | Sep 2026 | Nov 2025 |
| Registry versions | 3 | 106 |
| Documented tools | not extracted - see README | not extracted - see README |
| Env vars extracted | 1 | none extracted - see README |
| Runs | local (stdio) | local (stdio) |
| Endpoint auth | local only | local only |
| Maintenance | actively maintained | actively maintained |
| License | MIT | MIT |
| Language | Python | Python |
| Category rank | #3 of 241 | #2 of 241 |
Environment variables found in the READMEs
These are extracted names, not a requiredness check. Project docs may mark them optional or require other setup.
Excel MCP Server
- EXCEL_MCP_AUTH_TOKEN
Ha MCP
No environment variables were extracted from the README setup. Check the project documentation for other authentication or configuration steps.
Which one, for what
Derived from the signals above, not hands-on testing.
Pick Excel MCP Server if…
- → category standing - #3 of 241 maintained automation servers
Pick Ha MCP if…
- → measured package adoption matters - 284,284 monthly installs
- → category standing - #2 of 241 maintained automation servers
Who's behind them
Excel MCP Server - haris-musa: 1 MCP server tracked, 1 maintained, 4,205 combined stars.
Ha MCP - homeassistant-ai: 1 MCP server tracked, 1 maintained, 4,894 combined stars.
Not sold on either?
The next-ranked automation servers we track:
Quick answers
Is Excel MCP Server better than Ha MCP?
Package installs favor Ha MCP: 284,284 monthly installs to 132,122. Excel MCP Server still ranks #3 of 241 maintained automation servers. Data as of 2026-09-30; we haven't hands-on tested either.
Can I use Excel MCP Server and Ha MCP together?
Yes - MCP clients accept multiple servers in one config, so you can enable both automation servers side by side. If their tools overlap, keep the one whose toolset fits to keep your agent's tool list lean.
What environment variables do their READMEs document?
Excel MCP Server: 1 environment variable extracted from the README setup; Ha MCP: no environment variables extracted from the README setup. Extraction does not rule out other authentication or configuration steps; check each project's current documentation.
Keep exploring: best automation servers · Python servers · all comparisons · every server
Methodology: package-usage signal = npm/PyPI installs (last month, platform APIs) · maintenance = commit recency + release cadence (GitHub) · tool lists and environment-variable names extracted from each project's README · endpoint auth from our own nightly probes. We haven't hand-tested these servers; everything here is data as of 2026-09-30.